by Wes R / October 26, 2024
Is Sharpie the only marker for all your marker needs? Not if you want to save money without losing any of the quality…
Sharpie vs. Shuttle Art Permanent Markers: A Quality Comparison
When it comes to household names in permanent markers, Sharpie has been a favorite for years. But now, Shuttle Art is rising in popularity, offering a very similar quality at a much lower price. If you’re on the fence about which brand to choose, this guide will help you understand the pros, cons, and differences between these two options. And if you’re looking for quality without breaking the bank, you may find that Shuttle Art is a compelling choice. Please note that this article contains Amazon affiliate links. Any purchases made through these links help support our site. Thank you!
| Marker | Approx. Price Range (per marker) | Price Rating ($ – $$$$$) |
| Sharpie (Black) Permanent Markers | 12-pack (~$0.83*); 36-pack (~$0.58*) *prices are when the item is on sale | $$$ |
| Sharpie (Colored) Permanent Markers | 12-pack (~$0.75*); 24-pack (~$0.71*) *prices are when the item is on sale | $$$ |
| Shuttle Art (Black) Permanent Markers | 24-pack (~$0.42); 70-pack (~$0.34) | $ |
| Shuttle Art (Colored) Permanent Markers | 24-pack (~$0.42) | $ |
Sharpie Permanent Markers
Pros:
- Vibrant Colors: Sharpie markers are known for their vibrant, bold colors that work well on many surfaces.
- Variety of Sizes and Tips: Sharpie offers a wide variety of tip sizes (ultra-fine, fine, chisel, etc.) and has specialized markers for different uses.
- Reliability: These markers are famous for their durability and high quality, making them a trusted brand for years.
- Quick-Drying Ink: The ink dries quickly to prevent smearing, making it ideal for projects on the go.
Cons:
- Pricey: Sharpies tend to be more expensive, especially for large packs. For example, a 12-pack of black Sharpies costs approximately $0.83 per marker (on sale), and the colored 12-pack costs about $0.75 per marker.
- Ink Bleed: Sharpies are powerful, but their ink can sometimes bleed through thinner paper.
Overall Impression: Sharpie remains a solid option for those looking for reliable, high-quality permanent markers, particularly for smaller projects or professional work where brand consistency is essential.
Shuttle Art Permanent Markers
Pros:
- Affordable Pricing: Shuttle Art markers are a bargain, with prices averaging around $0.42 per black marker for a 24-pack and as low as $0.34 per marker in a 70-pack. This affordability means you get more markers for your money.
- Colorful and Bold Ink: Like Sharpies, Shuttle Art permanent markers offer vivid colors that work well on various surfaces.
- Long-Lasting: Customers report that Shuttle Art markers maintain their ink over time, comparable to the longevity of Sharpie markers.
- Non-Toxic and Safe: Shuttle Art markers are also non-toxic, making them safe for a variety of projects, including those around children.
Cons:
- Limited Variety in Tip Styles: Unlike Sharpie, Shuttle Art has fewer options for tip styles and sizes. Their selection is more straightforward, usually focusing on fine and medium-point markers.
- Minor Ink Variation: While Shuttle Art markers generally match Sharpie’s quality, some users have noted slight color variations in certain packs, though these differences are typically subtle.
Overall Impression: Shuttle Art permanent markers deliver nearly identical quality to Sharpie at a fraction of the cost. While they may lack a few specialty options, for general use and value, Shuttle Art markers are difficult to beat.
In Summary: Sharpie vs. Shuttle Art
| Feature | Sharpie | Shuttle Art |
|---|---|---|
| Average Price (Black) | ~$0.58 – $0.83 per marker | ~$0.34 – $0.42 per marker |
| Color Options | Excellent, large range | Great, comparable selection |
| Tip Variety | Many options (fine, ultra-fine) | Limited but standard sizes |
| Ink Quality | Vibrant, quick-drying | Bold, slightly longer drying |
| Bleed Potential | High on thin paper | Moderate, depends on paper |
Why Shuttle Art is the New Contender
Shuttle Art is making waves because it delivers almost everything Sharpie does—bold colors, reliable performance, and multi-surface use—but at a much lower price. If you’re someone who uses permanent markers frequently, whether for school projects, DIY crafts, or labeling, the cost savings with Shuttle Art add up quickly.
Final Verdict
Sharpie’s brand reputation is well-earned, and it still shines for professional use or specific applications requiring its signature tip variety and color range. But Shuttle Art has proven that you can have similar quality without the premium price tag. In everyday situations, from art projects to general household use, Shuttle Art can confidently hold its own as an alternative to Sharpie.
Whether you stick with Sharpie or try Shuttle Art, both offer quality that fits different needs and budgets. If you’re ready to save without compromising on quality, Shuttle Art may just be the next household name in permanent markers.
Again, please note that this article, our website, and the links provided are all promoting Amazon affiliate links. Any purchases made through these links help support our site. Thank you!